Posting Papers on ArXiv

Some have asked about posting preprints or reprints of articles submitted to JGR Space Physics on the website. The official AGU position on this issue is clear but not explicitly spelled out for the particular case of arXiv. The pertinent link is AGU’s dual publication policy that includes these lines:

“Posting of a preprint of an article via electronic media does not constitute prior publication unless with a service which provides archiving with citation protocols and public retrieval capabilities. In the latter case removal of the preprint from the archive will be sufficient for AGU to consider it as unpublished.”

While the arXiv site does not assign a digital object identifier resolvable at, the website follows a standardized “citation protocol” and is fully citable in the reference list of another paper. The short answer to the question of, “Can I post my JGR Space Physics preprint on arXiv?” is “no.”

You can, however, post it to your own personal website. If you do this, then please follow AGU’s policy on such postings and clearly state that it has been submitted to JGR Space Physics. After acceptance, then please change the statement to say, “accepted for publication with JGR Space Physics.” In fact, at this point, it is best to give proper reference and include the DOI so that others can go the AGU/Wiley page where it is located. After publication, the formatted “published” version can only be made available elsewhere is the author pays for Open Access. If you have paid this extra fee, then please feel free to post the Wiley-formatted version of the article wherever you choose. Otherwise, only the “unformatted manuscript” (i.e., the final submitted/accepted version without the Wiley publication-ready formatting) can be posted on your website, again clearly stating that it is “published in JGR Space Physics.”

Six months after publication, the formatted version can now be placed into an “institutional archive,” which includes the site, as long as the copyright information and official DOI of the paper is clearly posted.

Finally, twenty-four months after publication, the formatted version becomes Open Access at the Wiley site (for those that didn’t pay the Open Access fee earlier).

In short, AGU does not want you to post preprints to arXiv of your work that will be or has been submitted to an AGU journal. Because arXiv has a citation protocol, it counts as a publication and therefore such posting counts as dual publication. Yes, it counts even though it is not peer reviewed when posted at that site. Only after it has been accepted and published in the AGU journal can it be made available at arXiv, with a reference listing that directs the reader to the AGU version of the paper.


6 thoughts on “Posting Papers on ArXiv

  1. I also appreciate the clarity of the policy, since some other journals leave it very much unstated. Unfortunately, though, the actual content of the policy means that I will most likely refrain from publishing in AGU journals in the future. For those of us who cross between the solar physics, space physics, and astronomy communities, arXiv is THE primary gathering place for learning about new research from our colleagues. Disallowing the posting of preprints at the submission or “in-press” stages pretty much cuts off this avenue of early discovery.

    I’ll certainly be bringing this up with any AGU officers or Council members that I come across. Hopefully it can be changed in the future.

  2. Pingback: Soliciting Input on arXiv | Notes from the JGR-Space Physics Editor-in-Chief

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s