Policy Change Regarding arXiv

I don’t usually (ever?) make two posts in a single day, but this breaking news deserves immediate dissemination to the space physics community. The AGU Council Leadership Team has approved a revision of the publication policy to allow preprint postings on arXiv! Please read the full policy statement here:

http://publications.agu.org/author-resource-center/publication-policies/dual-publication-policy/

The revision is in the third paragraph, which now reads as follows:

“Previously published explicitly does not include oral or poster presentations, meeting abstracts or student theses/dissertations. AGU does allow posting of preprints and accepted papers in not-for-profit preprint servers that are designed to facilitate community engagement and discovery across the sciences.  Any other online publication with a service that provides archiving with citation protocols and public retrieval capabilities constitutes prior publication.”

By “not-for-profit preprint servers” they specifically mean arxiv.org and subservers related to it, like /astro-ph and /space-ph.

This change is, I think, being implemented because of feedback from the space physics community, in particular solar physicists. The message came through loud and clear that arXiv is a useful tool for sharing pre-publication science results, much like a conference but in written form, but that it is clearly understood by its users that it is not a replacement for publication in an archival, peer-reviewed journal. In fact, I am told that regular arXiv users know that if a preprint record is not eventually updated with a link to a final version in an archival journal, then the results should be treated with suspicion. Therefore, we should trust the community to use arXiv only as a preprint exchange of ideas and to keep sending manuscripts to peer-reviewed journals.

I especially like that it is open to upload at any time relative to submission/acceptance. I think this is critical because papers can be rejected from one journal and then resubmitted to another. There was discussion of allowing upload to arXiv only after submission (but still before acceptance). Uploading to arXiv at this point would be risky, then, if there is some chance that the initial journal could reject it. Subsequent “initial submissions” to a new journal would be after the arXiv upload. We have a hierarchy of AGU journals, where authors will first submit to GRL, then if rejected, modify it and submit it to JGR or Radio Science, and if rejected again, then they can now submit it to Earth and Space Science. The new policy allows upload to arXiv prior to initial submission because the submission might not actually be the first journal submission for that manuscript.

With a lot of input from you, the AGU Publications Committee heard the case for and against allowing preprints at arXiv and voted for full openness at this and similar not-for-profit, non-DOI-issuing sites. This was passed up the committee chain to the AGU Council, who approved it late last week. I would like to extend a special thank you to Brooks Hanson for shepherding this policy change request through the committee tree; it couldn’t have happened without his support. I would also like to thank all of you that responded to the calls for input on this subject, emailed me directly, or talked with me in person. The overwhelmingly positive feedback on arXiv usage made a significant difference in persuading people to vote for this change.

So, the ban is lifted! Please feel free to make full use of arXiv and submit preprints that have been uploaded to that site to JGR Space Physics.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s